The precautionary principle and the expanding moral circle for animal sentience in Jonathan Birch's proposal

Vargas-Chaves I. · Journal of Animal Behaviour and Biometeorology (2025) · DOI: 10.31893/jabb.2025032

Resumen

This paper explores the emerging application of the precautionary principle for animal sentiment to companion animal adoption practices. The study's objective was to determine the extent to which this principle can foster more ethically defensible, proactive, and welfare-centric adoption outcomes. Employing a methodology of documentary analysis, this research critically reviewed Birch's primary work alongside relevant literature in animal welfare science and adoption ethics, focusing on the principle's foundational tenets: the definition of sentience, the epistemic rule for inferring sentience, and the decision rule for action. The results indicate that Birch's framework offers a compelling rationale for a paradigm shift in adoption, mandating enhanced adopter screening, comprehensive counseling, ongoing postadoption support, and innovative precautionary clauses in adoption contracts. While acknowledging potential challenges such as increased resource demands and privacy concerns, the findings suggest that these challenges are manageable through carefully calibrated measures. In conclusion, applying the precautionary principle to companion animal adoption is a necessary advancement toward more ethically sound, welfare-centric practices, urging a move from transactional views to a covenant of care. This requires systemic engagement, including standardized guidelines and supportive legal structures. Copyright

Instituciones: Universidad Señor de Sipán